League September 2025 (Penny Dreadful) Decks

MTGGoldfish is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission.

League September 2025

Format: Penny Dreadful
Date: 2025-10-03

Place	Deck	Pilot	Tabletop Price	MTGO Price	Toggle Deck
2 - 3	Affinity	cragnok	$ 105	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Orzhov Humans	darvill	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Mono Black Control	excylis	$ 46	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Wizards	genesissloth	$ 97	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Wizards	gerry_lo_speziato	$ 112	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Izzet Control	hammeh	$ 22	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Greenpost	herr_braun	$ 73	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Ramp	ihateoko	$ 220	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	The Rock	jaycearveduin	$ 67	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Lumbertwin	jippiedoe	$ 130	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Artifact Midrange	jonsnow214	$ 96	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Archfiend Alteration	josha6337	$ 49	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Lumbertwin	josha6337	$ 130	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	josha6337	$ 183	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Possibility Storm	josha6337	$ 131	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Squirrel Aristocrats	josha6337	$ 177	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	The Rock	josha6337	$ 140	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Archfiend Alteration	klaus_vangliff	$ 38	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Izzet Control	kolthau	$ 45	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	kolthau	$ 128	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Dredge	natewellsir	$ 41	3 tix	Expand

2 - 3	The Rock	nedo92	$ 134	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Spirits	pyrohorse	$ 41	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Carth Superfriends	ramia94	$ 134	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	ryanthephyrexian	$ 128	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Citadel Storm	shalleftw	$ 169	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Fake-Rack	shalleftw	$ 57	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Lumbertwin	snakeadee001	$ 131	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Orzhov Humans	strategia	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Orzhov Humans	strategia	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Selesnya Heroic	superduper1	$ 126	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Sultai Tendrils	walkertm1	$ 45	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Red Deck Wins	xxdragonbornxx	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Red Deck Wins	xxdragonbornxx	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	_onecurlyboy	$ 150	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Lumbertwin	ailith	$ 141	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Fake-Rack	ayounggelfling	$ 50	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Toughness Matters	cippdogg	$ 177	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Lifegain Midrange	coupoutous	$ 269	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Orzhov Control	coupoutous	$ 80	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Orzhov Humans	darvill	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Jeskai Control	finaldefiance	$ 77	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Sultai Tendrils	finaldefiance	$ 60	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Ramp	growe11	$ 209	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Azorius Control	honorbound84	$ 38	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Orzhov Humans	khrolar	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Sultai Tendrils	natewellsir	$ 56	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Squirrel Aristocrats	nedo92	$ 175	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Azorius Control	quanjano	$ 39	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Possibility Storm	ragnarosthefirelord	$ 131	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	rolfusrex	$ 146	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Red Deck Wins	smokage	$ 73	3 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Five Color Hero	snakeadee001	$ 95	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Lumbertwin	snakeadee001	$ 130	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	swiftwarkite2	$ 146	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Sultai Ultimatum	thatonegamer4202	$ 69	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Combo	tomsoniq	$ 38	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Midrange	tomsoniq	$ 156	2 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Mono White Humans	wizard2222	$ 23	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Red Deck Wins	xxdragonbornxx	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Lifegain Midrange	zedzero	$ 209	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	_onecurlyboy	$ 151	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Mono Green Stompy	beardmeister	$ 72	3 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Sultai Tendrils	biffo_gc	$ 29	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Possibility Storm	coupoutous	$ 131	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Wizards	drinkwater	$ 117	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Dimir Control	finaldefiance	$ 72	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Rakdos Midrange	finaldefiance	$ 49	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Cawblade	honorbound84	$ 41	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Izzet Twin	ihateoko	$ 84	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Lumbertwin	kizawski	$ 122	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Archfiend Alteration	klaus_vangliff	$ 60	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Possibility Storm	lmayo	$ 131	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Oops All Lands	lucyferinthesky	$ 98	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Prison	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 127	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Lifegain Midrange	miguelmtg	$ 205	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Sultai Tendrils	oldcrimes	$ 56	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	slowpoke42	$ 160	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Red Deck Wins	smokage	$ 73	3 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Oops All Lands	snakeadee001	$ 98	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Mono White Cloudpost Control	sonatasunlight	$ 53	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Fight Rigging	superduper1	$ 157	3 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Game Objects	swamp_thing	$ 127	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Game Objects	swamp_thing	$ 128	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Gruul Midrange	swamp_thing	$ 115	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Oops All Lands	swiftwarkite2	$ 91	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Combo	tomsoniq	$ 40	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Combo	tomsoniq	$ 93	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Jeskai Midrange	tomsoniq	$ 83	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Jeskai Midrange	tomsoniq	$ 87	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Resurgent Belief	tomsoniq	$ 65	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	walkertm1	$ 145	2 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Red Deck Wins	walkertm1	$ 39	1 tix	Expand

1 - 1	Death Cloud	yuu200180128	$ 113	2 tix	Expand

Displaying 201 - 300 of 595 in total.

New Cards Being Played

Card	Decks
Evolving Wilds #153 (43)	Lich Aggro-Control (-) , Ramp (2 - 3) , Sultai Tendrils (1 - 1) , Sultai Tendrils (-) , Azorius Control (1 - 4) , ...
Assassin's Trophy #55 (32)	The Rock (2 - 3) , Death Cloud (3 - 2) , Five Color Hero (-) , Sultai Midrange (-) , The Rock (-) , ...
Dragonskull Summit #64 (21)	Elementals (-) , Goblins (-) , Seismic Swans (1 - 2) , Goblins (-) , Goblins (4 - 1) , ...
Hinterland Harbor #371 (19)	Game Objects (1 - 1) , Simic Post (1 - 3) , Game Objects (1 - 1) , Midrange (-) , Ramp (1 - 0) , ...
Acidic Slime #48 Marauding Mutagen (10)	Blink (-) , Simic Post (1 - 3) , Graveyard Value (3 - 1) , Graveyard Value (-) , Gruul Midrange (-) , ...
Waste Not #117 (8)	Fake-Rack (-) , Fake-Rack (1 - 0) , Fake-Rack (1 - 4) , Fake-Rack (1 - 2) , Fake-Rack (2 - 3) , ...
Grand Coliseum #68 (8)	Aggro (-) , Five Color Hero (-) , Five Color Hero (3 - 0) , Five Color Hero (-) , Five Color Hero (1 - 4) , ...
Sunken Hollow #322 (6)	Superfriends (-) , Combo (-) , Superfriends (-) , Dredge (-) , Dredge (-) , ...
Cultivate #50 (4)	Gruul Midrange (1 - 1) , Ramp (1 - 0) , Ramp (4 - 1) , Gruul Landfall (-)
Chromatic Lantern #58 (4)	Five Color Hero (-) , Five Color Hero (3 - 0) , Five Color Hero (-) , Five Color Hero (1 - 4)
Blasphemous Act #47 (4)	Combo (3 - 2) , Izzet Twin (4 - 1) , Izzet Twin (4 - 1) , Izzet Twin (4 - 1)
Smoldering Marsh #168 (3)	Elementals (-) , Combo (-) , Rakdos Aggro (1 - 2)
Cinder Glade #295 (2)	Ramp (1 - 0) , Ramp (4 - 1)
Rootbound Crag #163 (2)	Gruul Midrange (-) , Ponza (-)

Metagame Summary

Deck	Percentage	Total
Other	48.24%	287
Izzet Twin	7.56%	45
Sultai Tendrils	4.71%	28
Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	3.70%	22
Orzhov Humans	2.69%	16
Combo	2.35%	14
Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	2.18%	13
Five Color Hero	2.18%	13
The Rock	2.02%	12
Goblins	1.68%	10
Wizards	1.68%	10
Possibility Storm	1.68%	10
Azorius Control	1.68%	10
Restore Balance	1.51%	9
Seismic Swans	1.51%	9
Greenpost	1.51%	9
Mono Green Stompy	1.34%	8
Dredge	1.01%	6
Death Cloud	1.01%	6
Archfiend Alteration	1.01%	6
Fake-Rack	1.01%	6
Hero of Precinct One	0.84%	5
Gruul Midrange	0.84%	5
Prison	0.67%	4
Cycling Control	0.67%	4
Shadow Crimes	0.50%	3
Midrange	0.50%	3
Enchantress	0.50%	3
Hardened Scales Affinity	0.50%	3
Citadel Storm	0.50%	3
Spirits	0.50%	3
Mono Black Aggro	0.34%	2
Mono Red Devotion	0.17%	1
Anvil Colossus	0.17%	1
Boros Legends Aggro	0.17%	1
Gyruda	0.17%	1
Mono White Angels	0.17%	1
LifeScam	0.17%	1
Primal Prayers Combo	0.17%	1
Orzhov Control	0.17%	1
Total	100.00%	595

Most-Played Cards

Top Cards
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Memory Lapse B	531	26%
2	Birds of Paradise #439 Borderless	504	23%
3	Pithing Needle #378 Extended	474	37%
4	Fanatic of Rhonas #152	388	17%
5	Price of Progress #1026	378	16%
6	Mana Leak #58	371	20%
7	Burst Lightning #109	315	16%
8	Void Mirror #242	295	23%
9	Mogg Fanatic #138	292	13%
10	Nature's Rhythm #150	291	13%

Top Creatures
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Birds of Paradise #439 Borderless	504	23%
2	Fanatic of Rhonas #152	388	17%
3	Mogg Fanatic #138	292	13%
4	Scrapshooter #191	231	11%
5	Keldon Marauders #136	224	9%
6	Viashino Pyromancer #634	216	9%
7	Goblin Chainwhirler #129	215	15%
8	Scab-Clan Berserker #160	215	15%
9	Orcish Lumberjack	204	9%
10	Bloodfeather Phoenix #132	196	8%

Top Spells
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Memory Lapse B	531	26%
2	Pithing Needle #378 Extended	474	37%
3	Price of Progress #1026	378	16%
4	Mana Leak #58	371	20%
5	Burst Lightning #109	315	16%
6	Void Mirror #242	295	23%
7	Nature's Rhythm #150	291	13%
8	Thunder Magic #165	283	16%
9	Alpine Moon #128	272	19%
10	Incinerate #184	251	11%